Scientists call for overhaul of corporate carbon accounting

A group of leading climate researchers has warned that corporate carbon accounting is failing to support meaningful emissions reductions, calling for a new framework to improve the quality and reliability of emissions data used by businesses and policymakers.

The warning comes in a peer-reviewed academic paper backed by Cambridge-based climate technology company Neutreeno. The authors, who have advised organisations including the United Nations, the White House and international standards bodies, argue that current carbon accounting systems rely on data that is often too inaccurate to drive effective decarbonisation.

According to the researchers, more than 75% of a company’s greenhouse gas emissions typically occur within its supply chain, where businesses often depend on industry-average emissions estimates rather than supplier-specific data. They argue that these estimates can differ from actual emissions by as much as tenfold, limiting companies’ ability to identify where emissions reductions can be achieved.

The paper introduces a proposed framework known as the CSA Principles, which the authors say is designed to improve emissions reporting by ensuring data is credible, scalable and actionable. Rather than replacing existing reporting standards, the framework is intended to strengthen them by introducing quality metrics that identify where emissions data is reliable and where greater accuracy is needed.

Lead author Dr Spencer Brennan, founder of Neutreeno, said the current system was designed primarily for compliance rather than emissions reduction. He argued that companies cannot effectively cut carbon emissions if they do not have confidence in the underlying data used to measure them.

The researchers say the issue comes at a time when climate policy is facing increasing pressure. They point to recent changes in environmental regulation in Europe and the United States, including the European Union’s plans to ease some emissions reporting requirements for industrial facilities and policy shifts by the US Environmental Protection Agency, as evidence that businesses may face less regulatory oversight in the coming years.

Against that backdrop, the authors argue that improving the quality of corporate emissions data has become increasingly important if businesses are to meet net zero commitments and provide investors with credible climate disclosures.

The researchers are calling on governments, regulators, investors and businesses to adopt the CSA Principles, saying higher-quality carbon accounting will be essential to accelerating industrial decarbonisation and restoring confidence in corporate climate reporting.

Growing scrutiny of corporate sustainability claims has increased demand for more accurate emissions reporting, particularly for Scope 3 emissions generated across supply chains. As companies face mounting pressure to demonstrate measurable progress towards climate targets, the debate over the reliability of carbon accounting is expected to play an increasingly important role in shaping future climate policy and corporate reporting standards.

Back to top button