Agricultural circular economy sidelined in net-zero plans, APEC survey finds

A survey of APEC member economies has found that circular agriculture remains a secondary instrument within regional decarbonisation strategies, with most respondents estimating that it accounts for less than half of the emissions reductions needed to meet their net-zero commitments, and with weak carbon accounting infrastructure limiting the sector’s ability to access carbon finance.
The findings were compiled by the Agricultural Technology Research Institute of Chinese Taipei as part of a project delivered under the Agricultural Technical Cooperation Working Group, and were presented at a three-day workshop held in Kaohsiung in September 2025 attended by 125 delegates from 14 member economies alongside 20 invited speakers. Ten valid survey responses were received from eight economies.
All respondents reported having circular agriculture policies in place, and five said their programmes had been running for more than five years, including two with over a decade of implementation. Financial commitment, however, was described as modest. Most economies reported annual budgets of between USD 1 million and USD 10 million, several reported under USD 1 million, and one had allocated no dedicated funding at all.
The most acute constraint identified was capital. Respondents scored insufficient funding and resources at 4.12 on a five-point scale, ahead of knowledge and technology gaps and unstable supply chains, both at 3.62. Delegates repeatedly returned to the finding that the agriculture, forestry and other land use sector receives roughly 4.3% of global climate finance, a figure participants said constrains investment in biogas installations, biomass recycling and waste-to-energy plant at farm and cooperative level.
Measurement capability emerged as a second bottleneck with direct implications for carbon crediting. Economies reported relying most heavily on emission factor approaches, scored at 4.0, and monitoring, reporting and verification systems at 3.75. More granular methods were far less common: life-cycle assessment scored 3.12, soil carbon and carbon credit mechanisms 2.75, and integrated assessment indicators just 2.12. Delegates concluded that inconsistent methodologies across economies undermine comparability of carbon footprint data and weaken the effectiveness of market-based mechanisms.
Eight of the ten respondents confirmed economy-wide net-zero targets, but only five had set explicit targets for the agricultural sector, with two answering no and three uncertain. Private sector engagement was rated moderate by four respondents and limited by three, with only one reporting extensive involvement. Government co-financing of private investment was generally reported below 50%, and in four cases below 30%.
Several economies set out crediting frameworks during the sessions. Chinese Taipei has developed a domestic carbon credit system with five methodologies available to the agricultural sector, covering afforestation, alternate wetting and drying in rice cultivation, forest and bamboo management, mangrove and seagrass restoration, and agricultural energy transformation. Legislation governing agricultural waste management and farmland use is being revised to permit biogas plants and similar facilities on agricultural land. The economy generated approximately 4.81 million tonnes of biological agricultural residues in 2023.
Japan outlined the role of its J-Credit scheme in monetising alternate wetting and drying, which cuts methane emissions from paddy cultivation by around 30% against continuous flooding, and described work with the Asian Development Bank on the first agricultural project in Asia under the Joint Crediting Mechanism. China’s delegation noted that livestock mitigation projects are being registered under the Verified Carbon Standard and the Gold Standard, supported by domestic accounting standard GB/T 44903-2024, and set out three technical pathways centred on feed efficiency, low-protein diets that cut nitrogen excretion by around 10%, and manure management.
New Zealand, where agriculture accounts for approximately 53% of gross emissions, has committed around NZD 400 million between 2024 and 2029 to develop soil and animal inhibitor technologies. Australia cited CSIRO modelling suggesting circular economy measures could reduce economy-wide emissions by 14% by 2035, supported by AUD 15 billion through the National Reconstruction Fund and AUD 37 million under the Food Waste for Healthy Soils Fund.
Project-level results were also presented. A demonstration dairy operation run by the Taiwan Livestock Research Institute reported annual reductions of about 1,003 tonnes CO₂e, while modelling combining biogas, solar photovoltaics and slurry injection produced a net position of approximately –269 tCO₂e a year. Shih An Farm, an egg producer, reported a 46% cut in product carbon footprint between 2019 and 2023, to roughly 0.179 kg CO₂e per kilogram of eggs.
Respondents ranked technology transfer at 4.38 and capacity building at 4.25 as the priority areas for future regional cooperation, ahead of financing, joint research and market cooperation.
